Blog

Profitless Prosperity (part 4): Becoming Non-Discretionary in a Discretionary World

Written by Chris Scherer | Feb 16, 2026 4:30:32 PM

Every recession reshuffles the same deck.

Manufacturing contracts.
Capital spending slows.
Consumers defer.
Projects get postponed.

And yet, some businesses remain remarkably stable.

Why?

Because they are not discretionary.

They are necessary.

The Quiet Pattern Across Recessions

Historically, discretionary industries absorb the sharpest impact during economic contractions.
Non-discretionary services – food distribution, medical services, pharmaceuticals, electrification, infrastructure, utilities – tend to hold far more stable ground.

The difference is not luck.

It is position.

Discretionary businesses depend on:

  • Timing
  • Sentiment
  • Available capital
  • Customer confidence

Non-discretionary businesses depend on:

  • Need
  • Continuity
  • Operational necessity
  • Survival

The question leaders should be asking now is simple:

If pressure increases, will customers view what we provide as optional – or essential?

Why This Matters Before 2030

ITR Economics has warned that the road ahead will be uneven, with volatility increasing toward the next decade.

Revenue may grow in the short term.

But when cycles turn, customers triage.

They eliminate what they can delay.

They preserve what they cannot operate without.

If your value is framed as enhancement rather than necessity, margin protection becomes exponentially harder.

Becoming “Essential” Is a Leadership Decision

You do not need to change industries to become more resilient.

You may need to change how your value is defined.

Organizations that reposition successfully typically:

1️⃣ Redefine their offering around continuity

Instead of selling:

  • Projects
  • Customization
  • Enhancements

They anchor value in:

  • Operational uptime
  • Risk reduction
  • Compliance
  • Reliability

They move from “improvement” to “indispensable.”

2️⃣ Remove optional complexity

Discretionary models often carry:

  • Custom exceptions
  • Broad service menus
  • Unpriced expectations
  • Undefined service boundaries

These increase fragility.

Resilient organizations clarify:

  • What is included
  • What is excluded
  • What triggers escalation
  • What success looks like

Clarity stabilizes margin.

3️⃣ Govern relationships intentionally

Becoming non-discretionary requires trust.

Trust requires structure.

That means:

  • Defined roles and responsibilities
  • Measurable service levels
  • Mutually understood outcomes
  • Accountability mechanisms before failure

When expectations are explicit and performance is visible, customers depend on you differently.

You are no longer an option.

You are infrastructure.

The Margin Impact of Indispensability

When customers view your work as essential:

  • Price discussions shift
  • Renewal risk decreases
  • Vendor negotiations stabilize
  • Employees understand purpose

Margin protection becomes proactive rather than reactive.

This is not about raising prices aggressively.

It’s about designing your business so pricing reflects necessity.

The Strategic Question Leaders Must Answer

Before the next downturn accelerates:

  • Is your revenue driven by enhancement or necessity?
  • Is your value tied to sentiment or survival?
  • Are your agreements designed to hold under stress?

If the answer is unclear, growth alone will not protect you.

Position will.

What Comes Next

In Part 5, we’ll explore the final lever leaders must confront:

Why hiring more people rarely solves margin pressure – and how adding capacity without redesigning leadership systems accelerates profitless prosperity.

📅 [Schedule a Strategy Alignment Session]
Let’s determine whether your business is positioned as essential – or treated as optional.